Our order pick up area will be OPEN on New Year's Eve until 4pm and CLOSED on New Year's Day (Thursday 1/1).

Shop our New Year’s collection now for the most popular items to kick off the New Year!

The limited edition 2026 Winter Roast coffee is here to enjoy! With flavors of cinnamon and caramel, it makes a wonderful gift.

Kettle Cooked Apple Butter

Slowly cooked until thick and rich.
Choose from Apple, Peach, or Pear Butter in the drop down menu.

Apple, Peach, or Pear!

$6.95

A Pennsylvania Dutch favorite!  Apple butter (along with both pear and peach butter) are spreadable preserves made by slow-cooking apples (or pears/peaches) for a long time over low heat, caramelizing them and concentrating their flavor. 

We enjoy apple butter on toast with butter, as a condiment with breakfast sausage or bratwurst, on pancakes, as a topping for cottage cheese, as a sandwich with peanut butter and apple butter, as a dip for fruits and veggies, stirred into oatmeal, and more!

Ingredients

Apples and apple cider