Thanksgiving turkey reservations are openThanksgiving turkeys--Daysd--Hrsh--Minm--SecsReserve yoursSave 💵 while shopping our limited time Clearance Corner!🥩 Shop Ancestral Beef Stick Bites—Nutrient-Dense Protein on the Go 🍶 New EXTRA THICK Greek A2/A2 Yogurt!

Butter

Traditionally Crafted · Truly Nourishing

Exceptional Butter Makes Everything Better

Rich, flavorful 100% grass-fed A2/A2 cultured Butter from Elmer & Sarah’s. Made in small batches in the traditional European style, it brings delicious character to warm bread, homemade baking and the finishing touch on dinner.

Grass-Fed Beginnings

Made with dairy from pasture-raised, 100% grass-fed A2/A2 cows at Elmer & Sarah’s family farm.

Cultured for Flavor

Traditional European-style culturing develops a full, rounded flavor worth savoring—even on a simple slice of toast.

Salted or Unsalted

Choose Salted for spreading and finishing, or Unsalted for baking and recipes where you want control over the seasoning.

✓ 100% grass-fed A2/A2 dairy ✓ Small-batch cultured Butter ✓ Salted & Unsalted options

100% Grass Fed A2/A2 Salted Butter - Paper Wrapped

9 oz. Lightly pasteurized. Cultured (European style)

Save $1.55
$12.95
$14.50

100% Grass Fed A2/A2 Unsalted Butter - Paper Wrapped

9 oz. Lightly pasteurized. Cultured (European style)

Save $1.55
$12.95
$14.50

Traditional Cultured Butter

A Simple Staple Worth Choosing Well

A pat melting over vegetables. A generous spread on warm sourdough. The rich foundation of a homemade pastry. Good Butter brings flavor, texture and satisfaction to familiar foods—and cultured Butter adds its own delicious depth.

Delicious Ways to Enjoy It

Spread & Savor

Spread Salted Butter over warm bread, tuck it into a baked potato, or let it melt over freshly cooked vegetables. Simple preparations let its cultured flavor shine.

Bake Something Beautiful

Choose Unsalted Butter for cookies, cakes and pastry. Follow your recipe’s temperature guidance: cold Butter helps create flaky layers, while softened Butter is useful for creaming with sugar.

Finish with Flavor

Add a small pat to a cooked Steak, toss with warm pasta, or stir into mashed potatoes. For pan sauces, whisk in cold Butter over gentle heat just before serving.

Make Your Own Herb Butter

Soften Butter and mix with finely chopped parsley, rosemary or chives. Add a little garlic or lemon zest, then refrigerate until firm. Slice a small pat over roasted Chicken, a sizzling Steak or warm vegetables for an easy finishing touch. If using Salted Butter, taste before adding more salt.

Golden Color, Seasonal Character

Butter from cows grazing green pasture can develop a deeper golden color from naturally occurring beta-carotene in the forage. Color and flavor may shift with the seasons— a natural feature of grass-fed dairy.

Product Details & Storage

Our Butter is lightly pasteurized and cultured; it is not raw. See individual product pages for ingredients, package size and current availability.

Keep refrigerated and follow the package guidance. Wrap well or store in a covered container to protect its flavor from refrigerator odors. Butter can also be frozen, tightly wrapped, for longer storage.

Warm Bread. Golden Pastry. A Delicious Finishing Touch.

From the first slice of toast to the finishing touch on dinner, good Butter makes everyday food a little more inviting. Keep a favorite on hand and enjoy the simple pleasure of cooking with rich, grass-fed cultured Butter.

Tussock Sedge Farm

Slowly Grown · Truly Nourishing