Thanksgiving turkey reservations are openThanksgiving turkeys--Daysd--Hrsh--Minm--SecsReserve yoursπŸ₯¨ New Einkorn Sourdough Soft Pretzels are here!!🍢 New EXTRA THICK Greek A2/A2 Yogurt!

Raw Cheese from Organic A2/A2 Grass Fed Milk

Assortment of handcrafted artisan cheeses

Traditionally crafted cheeses made from thoughtfully raised cow, goat, and sheep milk.

Most of our cheeses are handcrafted from raw milk, including a wide selection made with grass-fed A2/A2 cow milk. The collection also includes raw goat- and sheep-milk cheeses, along with a small number of carefully made cultured and artisan cheeses that are not raw, including Cottage Cheese and plain Goat Chevre.

Raw Mild Cheddar Cheese - 8oz block

Firm and creamy with a very mild taste.
Aged 2 to 4 months.

$10.94

Grand Reserve 10-Year Aged Raw Cheddar

A once in a lifetime cheese! 5 to 6 oz block.

Raw Sharp Cheddar Cheese - 8oz block

A medium sharp cheese.
Aged 6-10 months.
2nd place winner at PA Farm Show!

$11.94

Raw Reserve Cheddar Cheese - 8oz block

Aged up to 2 years!
Won 1st Place at the PA Farm Show!

$12.94

Raw Frolic Cheese

An alpine style cheese that is mild and melts well. 5 to 6 oz wedge.

Save $5.00
$9.50
$14.50

Raw Cave Aged Cheddar Cheese

Slowly aged in caves for up to 2 years. 5 to 6 oz block.

Baudolino Cheese

A creamy, fudgy texture! Soft-ripened. 5 to 6 oz wedge.

Raw Amish Schmearkase Cheese

Smooth and creamy! Great with ale, hearty breads, melts well! 5 to 6 oz wedge.

Save $5.00
$11.90
$16.90

Raw Amish Blue Cheese

The BEST blue ever! 5 to 6 oz wedge.

Raw Shredded Mild Cheddar Cheese - 1 pound bag!

Firm and creamy with a very mild taste.
Aged 2 to 4 months.

Raw Shredded Meadowrella Cheese - 1 pound bag!

A "mozzarella" type cheese.
Aged at least 2 months.

Raw Sheep's Milk Cheddar Cheese - 8oz block

Firm, extra creamy, and rich! 100% grass fed.
Aged 2 to 4 months.

Raw Applewood Cheddar Cheese - 8oz block

Full of rich flavor! An award winning cheese!

Raw Yogurt Cheese - 8oz block

Smooth and creamy. Full of probiotics!

Raw Gouda Cheese - 8oz block

A semi-hard cheese. Nutty with notes of caramel.

Raw Pepper Jack Cheese - 8oz block

Mild and creamy with just a little bit of kick!

Organic Cottage Cheese - 1 lb

From 100% Grass Fed pasture raised cows. Low heat pasteurized.

Cowsley Cheese Round

A fresh and tangy cheese. 1/4 lb rounds. Low-temp vat pasteurized

Save $5.00
$7.00
$12.00

Goat Chevre - Plain

6 oz. Mild and creamy. Low heat pasteurized

Raw Goat Cheese - Cheddar

8 oz block. Mild, firm and creamy

Raw Goat Cheese - Feta

8 oz block. Creamy and crumbly

Raw Goat Cheese - Gouda

8 oz block. Creamy, slighty sweet and nutty

Traditional Cheese with Real Character

Raw cheese begins with milk that has not been pasteurized. Traditional culturing, careful cheesemaking, and patient aging transform that milk into cheeses with remarkable depth, texture, and natural variation.

Our grass-fed A2/A2 cow-milk selections range from mild, creamy everyday cheeses to cave-aged and reserve varieties developed over months or even years. The collection also includes distinctive goat- and sheep-milk cheeses, each with its own flavor, texture, and traditional character.

Explore Mild and Sharp Cheddar, Meadowrella, Gouda, Swiss, Feta, Havarti, Pepper Jack, Blue Cheese, soft-ripened cheeses, long-aged reserve selections, Goat Cheese, Sheep’s Milk Cheese, Cottage Cheese, and more.

Living Cheese, Natural Variation

Traditionally made cheeses continue to develop as they age. Soft-ripened varieties may develop natural growth on the rind or occasional blue veining within the cheese. When this occurs in these traditionally made varieties, it is a natural and safe part of the aging processβ€”and something the cheesemakers celebrate for the additional complexity it can bring.

Natural variation in color, rind, texture, and flavor is expected from one batch to another. If you are ever uncertain about a cheese, please contact us and we will be happy to help.

Enjoying and Storing Your Cheese

Keep cheese refrigerated and sealed until you are ready to enjoy it. After opening, wrap it carefully and return it promptly to the refrigerator. For the fullest flavor and best texture, allow the portion you plan to serve to rest briefly at room temperature before eating.

Review each product page for the type of milk, aging time, flavor, texture, package size, producer information, and whether that particular cheese is made with raw milk.